Study recommends car toll for German highways to secure Autobahn GmbH financing
Confidential report advises the German Federal Government on introducing a medium-term car toll (Pkw-Maut) to finance the crucial maintenance and operation of German Autobahns.
A confidential expert report for the Federal Government reportedly suggests that implementing a car toll (Pkw-Maut) in the medium term is necessary to finance Germany's Autobahns. The "Spiegel" reports that this is an economic efficiency study related to the financial reform planned by Transport Minister Steffen Bilger (CDU) at the Autobahn GmbH. The study, prepared by the public consulting firm PD, has been classified as confidential.
The Autobahn GmbH is intended to be able to take on debt in the future, in return for which it would receive a portion of the revenue from the truck toll. Although the authors of the efficiency study view this as an improvement over the current status quo, their calculations indicate that the revenues are insufficient to cover the long-term investment needs and the borrowing costs of the Autobahn GmbH. Instead, they predict that the company will "continuously incur losses". Even if the permissible debt is capped at 20 billion euros, "significant pressure to increase revenues" is expected by early 2034.
PD models two alternative courses of action to achieve this goal. In the first scenario, the Autobahn GmbH would receive all revenues from the truck toll instead of just a portion. In the second scenario, in addition to the currently promised share of the truck toll, the company would also gain revenue from a "newly introduced, route-based car toll".
A percentage value relative to the respective total economic benefit was calculated for all variants. The result showed that the status quo performed the worst at 56.6 percent. Bilger's reform plans registered 65.8 percent. The model of a full truck toll was evaluated at 77.4 percent. This was narrowly surpassed by the combination of car and truck tolls, achieving 79.9 percent.
According to the report, the Autobahn GmbH would be most likely to remain financially stable and service its debts for the entire period considered, up to 2056, with the assistance of a car toll. Furthermore, both trucks and cars would have to pay. The authors praise this as "the closest approach to the polluter pays principle among the considered variants".
While the Autobahn GmbH would remain dependent on grants from the federal budget under Bilger's plans, the independence from such funds would be "significantly greater" with toll revenues. PD also stresses that this is relevant because the federal special fund for infrastructure and climate neutrality will expire starting in 2037, eliminating another source of state financing.
In their calculations, the authors assume that the Autobahn GmbH only needs to pay a moderate risk premium of approximately 0.5 percentage points compared to ten-year government bonds. They justify this by stating that an "implicitly existing state guarantee" is expected to "mitigate the risk premium in practice".
