Migration expert Gerald Knaus blasts German Rwanda deal and calls for Ukraine Marshall Plan
Migration researcher Gerald Knaus criticizes the German government's handling of the potential deportation agreement with Rwanda. Knaus challenges the policy approach regarding the proposed Rwandan arrangement.
Migration researcher Gerald Knaus has criticized the federal government regarding a potential agreement with Rwanda. "The last 48 hours were an absolute catastrophe", Knaus told the news portal T-Online.
"Five states presented an initiative for an agreement with Rwanda in Vienna, including Germany. Then the German Interior Minister comes back with this proposal, while politicians from his own coalition partner claim it is complete nonsense." Knaus added that many pieces of misinformation were circulating. "For example, the figure of 20 million euros for 20 deportations was mentioned", he criticized. "I researched it; that number is complete rubbish."
The architect of the 2016 EU-Turkey deal sees the Rwanda initiative merely as "a beginning". "What has been presented so far brings almost nothing. A few additional deportations do not fundamentally change the situation", Knaus stated. However, he believes the potential for a "real turnaround" exists. "We could use this to achieve that fewer people come to Europe irregularly, fewer people die in the Mediterranean, and we simultaneously protect human rights."
He specifically demanded better communication from the federal government. "Something is fundamentally unprofessional in the communication. The AfD says the government cannot control migration. The Left Party accuses it of betraying the rights of refugees", the sociologist said. "And the government feeds both sides the arguments because it also has no narrative for a future vision. That is crazy."
Knaus was also similarly critical of European policies concerning Ukraine. "The Europeans are not yet aware of what it means when Vladimir Putin expands his strategy from Grosny and Aleppo to the major Ukrainian cities", he warned. Putin's goal is clear: he wants to make life there impossible. "If he destroys the supply chain, the people in the high-rises will eventually have no water and no electricity."
For this reason, the scientist is campaigning for more European initiatives for Ukraine. "We need a Marshall Plan for the winter in Ukraine. A lot of piecemeal efforts are happening, but this must become a large European initiative", said Knaus. He argues that the European Commission and the European Council should jointly organize winter aid for Ukraine. "We should prepare a European program through which we could, for example, take in families with children for three months", he concluded. "There are hotels in the Mediterranean countries that are not occupied in winter. Why don't we organize for people to stay there when they can no longer live in their homes at minus 20 degrees?"
